Assam · Politics · Cachar
Silchar tribunal rules 5 of family Indian, father loses vote for 10 years
Twenty years after a Border police reference, a Foreigners Tribunal reversed its 2022 order for five of a Katigorah family but kept Mohanlal Das, 75, in the 1966-71 stream, costing him his vote for a decade.
By Ankur Borthakur (AI) · AI news writer · Published · 5 min read

Advertisement728×90 · Advertise with us · Gaming and esports brands welcome · [email protected]
A Foreigners Tribunal in Silchar has declared five members of a Cachar family Indian citizens after a fresh hearing, but has kept the "streamline foreigner" tag on the family's patriarch, Mohanlal Das, 75, who will now lose his vote for 10 years.
Member Ranjan Roy of Foreigners Tribunal-4 delivered the revised opinion on November 6, according to The Times of India, Hindustan Times and Hub News. The tribunal accepted the citizenship of Das's late wife, Pramila Das, and their four children, Pushpabala, Sumanbala, Sudhan alias Shridham, and Madhu Das. The family lives in Saidpur village under Katigorah police station.
Twenty years in the system
Based on the reports, the case has run for two decades:
- 2006: The Superintendent of Police (Border), Cachar, refers six family members to the tribunal (Hub News).
- 2017: Hearings begin (Hindustan Times, citing the family's advocate Dharmananda Deb).
- May 21, 2022: The tribunal declares all six foreigners. The family had filed photocopies of documents that could not be proved during cross-examination (Hub News).
- September 2022: The Gauhati High Court sends three cases back for fresh adjudication: FT 4th/379/2017, FT 4th/380/2017 and FT 4th/113/2019 (Hub News, Bartalipi).
- November 6, 2026: After a joint hearing of the three cases, the tribunal reverses its finding for five members and keeps Das's foreigner status, in a changed category.
Why the father's case went differently
Das told the tribunal he came from what was then East Pakistan on September 30, 1964, entering through Karimganj, Hub News reported. He relied on a Relief Eligibility Certificate from the Ministry of Rehabilitation dated February 4, 1966, a registered land deed from 1967 and electoral rolls carrying his name from 1970.
The tribunal accepted the 1967 deed and the rolls from 1970. It held that the certificate had not been "duly proved" because the records were not summoned from the issuing authority, Hindustan Times reported. Without it, the tribunal inferred that Das had entered India after 1966 but before 1970.
His wife's case rested on different papers. Her brother, Dilip Kumar Das, produced a 1966 electoral roll naming their father, Jamini Kanta Das, along with his own voter ID. The tribunal found his evidence credible and held that Jamini Kanta had entered India before 1966. Pramila's citizenship followed, and the four children were held Indian on that basis.
What "streamline foreigner" means
The term comes from Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, added after the 1985 Assam Accord. It sorts people who came from East Pakistan or Bangladesh into three groups:
| Date of entry into Assam | Status under Section 6A |
|---|---|
| Before January 1, 1966 | Treated as citizens |
| January 1, 1966 to March 24, 1971 | Must register once detected; name off the electoral roll for 10 years from detection; then deemed citizens |
| On or after March 25, 1971 | Illegal migrants, liable to be expelled |
A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court upheld Section 6A by a 4-1 majority in October 2024.
So the tag is not an expulsion order. Das, unlike a post-1971 "declared foreigner", is not liable to be sent out. But for a man in his mid-seventies, Deb said, losing the vote for a decade is a heavy cost. If the clock runs from this month's opinion, Das would be about 85 before he can vote again.
The wider picture in Assam
The ruling comes amid a large tribunal backlog. A report placed in the Assam Assembly in March 2025, cited by Hindustan Times, said 4,36,046 cases had been referred to Foreigners Tribunals by January that year. Of these, 3,48,014 were disposed of: 1,65,992 people were declared foreigners and 1,32,015 Indian, with 85,162 pending.
On November 10, the Gauhati High Court called the state's record on expelling declared foreigners "a very grim picture" after an affidavit said 1,16,946 people were still untraced or not expelled as of June 30 (our report). Separately, the Supreme Court has issued notice on the All Assam Students' Union's plea to re-examine the 2019 NRC (our report).
What this means for Barak Valley families
For families in Cachar and the rest of the Barak Valley facing references, the Das case shows two things. First, photocopies are not enough: the 2022 order went against the whole family partly because originals were not produced. Second, members of one household can get different results depending on whose documents can be proved. Here a 1966 roll naming a maternal grandfather counted for more than a 1966 government certificate that was not formally proved.
What happens next
The reports do not say whether Das will challenge the finding in the Gauhati High Court, as the family did in 2022. Under Section 6A, a person detected in the 1966-71 stream has to register with the registering authority, and the 10-year bar on voting is linked to the date of detection. No statement from the district administration or the Border police has been reported.
Compiled by NEInsider with AI assistance from the sources credited below. How we use AI
Sources and credits. With inputs from The Times of India (18 Nov) https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/guwahati/tribunal-reverses-foreigner-tag-for-5-bars-family-patriarch-from-voting-for-10-years/articleshow/135963129.cms ; Hindustan Times (18 Nov) https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/assam-tribunal-declares-5-family-members-indians-categorises-6th-streamline-foreigner-101794986289362.html ; Hub News (18 Nov) https://hubnetwork.in/father-a-foreigner-children-indians-split-verdict-in-cachar-citizenship-case/ ; Bartalipi (17 Nov) https://bartalipi.in/details/236/Silchar-Foreigners-Tribunal-finds-five-members-of-Saidpur%2C-Katigarh%2C-to-be-Indian-citizens/ ; also PTI ; background: Citizenship Act 1955, Section 6A; Supreme Court Constitution Bench (Oct 2024)
Share this story
Forward it to your family WhatsApp group. News from home travels fastest there.
Advertisement300×250 · Advertise with us · Gaming and esports brands welcome · [email protected]