Skip to content

Wed 18 Nov 2026

NEInsider
Breaking

Meghalaya · Politics · South West Khasi Hills

Meghalaya HC voids KHADC's Hima Maharam law over skipped House vote

The 2019 amendment recast Myntris in Raid Saw Symper as headmen with three-year terms. The court said the council's executive rewrote it after the Governor sent it back, skipping the House. The 2006 Act now applies.

By · AI news writer · Published · 5 min read

File photo: the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council building in Shillong, Meghalaya
File photo: the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council building in Shillong, Meghalaya. Photo: Ashish Bhatnagar (आशीष भटनागर) / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Meghalaya High Court has thrown out a 2019 Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council (KHADC) law that redefined village chiefs in part of Hima Maharam, ruling that the council's Executive Committee rewrote the Bill after the Governor sent it back, without a fresh House vote.

A division bench of Justice Hamarsan Singh Thangkhiew and Justice Biswadeep Bhattacharjee declared the Hima Maharam (Amendment) Act, 2019 ultra vires on Tuesday, November 17, Highland Post and the legal reporting site LawLens reported. The petitioners, Tolentine Wahlang and Haspingwel Kharhari, are from Nonglynkien and Mawtiehbah under Hima Maharam in South West Khasi Hills.

What the 2019 amendment tried to change

The parent law is the KHADC's 2006 Act on choosing the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and electors of Hima Maharam. Its text, on the state government's website, makes the Syiem (traditional chief) a life appointment, chosen by electors drawn from the Lyngdohs of six clans and the Myntris. Each Myntri heads a recognised village and is elected by its adult male residents at a meeting called by the Syiem and Durbar. The 2006 text fixes no term for a Myntri.

According to both reports, the amendment the KHADC passed on July 25, 2019 targeted only the Raid Saw Symper area of the Hima. It made three changes:

  • a proviso limiting the Act to village administration, leaving out land administration;
  • a clause saying the Myntri would also be known as the Rangbah Shnong, or headman;
  • a three-year term, with an election procedure, for the Myntri.

The petitioners argued that a Myntri is not a Rangbah Shnong and that the change was a demotion, and that the Dorbar Hima (the Hima's general assembly) was never consulted, Highland Post reported.

The six years between vote and verdict

The court's record, as summarised by LawLens:

  • 25 July 2019: KHADC passes the Bill by voice vote.
  • 17 October 2019: The Maharam Syiemship's objections to the Governor are forwarded to the council.
  • 15 February 2021: The department tells the KHADC the Bill has not received assent and asks it to reconsider.
  • 25 August 2023: The state Law Department advises dropping Clause 2 (land administration) and Clause 3 (Myntri as Rangbah Shnong).
  • 1 September 2023: The Executive Committee accepts the observations and resubmits the Bill, but only Clause 2 is removed; the Myntri provisions stay.
  • 15 and 26 September 2023: Governor's assent, then publication in the gazette.
  • 17 November 2026: High Court strikes the Act down.

Why the court said the procedure failed

The KHADC, represented by senior advocate Kaustav Paul, and the state, through Advocate General Amit Kumar, argued that there had been no formal return by the Governor, only Law Department notes, and that the edits were clerical, Highland Post reported.

The bench treated the August 2023 communication as a formal return under Rule 93 of the 1951 rules governing Assam and Meghalaya's district councils. That rule requires a returned Bill's changes to be debated and voted on in the House before resubmission. A 2019 vote, the court held, could not cover 2023 changes.

Highland Post quoted the judgment as saying the September 2023 letter showed substantial amendments "were never placed before the Chairman of the House for discussion or vote", which it called "a clear transgression of the executive into the legislative domain of the Council." LawLens noted the bench relied on Supreme Court rulings including Kihoto Hollohan, and held that the Governor's assent could not cure the defect. The court did not rule on the custom question; its finding is about procedure only.

What it means for Raid Saw Symper and the councils

With the amendment gone, the 2006 Act applies unaltered across Hima Maharam. In Raid Saw Symper, that means a Myntri is not legally recast as a Rangbah Shnong and has no three-year term, Highland Post noted.

The wider impact is on law-making in all three of Meghalaya's district councils. Highland Post read the ruling as binding on the Khasi, Jaintia and Garo Hills councils: no Executive Committee can amend a returned Bill without a full House vote.

It is the second such rebuke this year. In August, Justice W Diengdoh quashed the KHADC's suspension of the Syiem of Hima Mylliem because the council skipped procedure in its own 2007 Mylliem Act, The Shillong Times reported.

The ruling also lands while the KHADC marks 75 years and promotes its role as guardian of Khasi customs, a jubilee NEInsider reported on in October, and as the council prepares its own High Court fight with the state over the Shillong Peak ropeway. In Tripura, the tribal council's vote this week to enlarge its executive likewise still awaits state and Governor approval (our report).

What happens next

The KHADC has not said publicly whether it will accept the verdict. Any challenge to a division bench ruling would go to the Supreme Court. The council could instead reintroduce the Myntri changes and put them to a House vote, the step the court found missing. We will update this story when the KHADC or state responds.

Compiled by NEInsider with AI assistance from the sources credited below. How we use AI

Sources and credits. With inputs from Highland Post (18 Nov) https://highlandpost.com/khadc-law-on-hima-maharam-quashed-by-high-court/ ; LawLens judgment summary, Tolentine Wahlang v. State of Meghalaya (17 Nov) https://lawlens.in/stories/meghalaya-hc-strikes-down-khasi-hills-council-s-syiem-amendment-act-saying-revised-changes-52210042f5a440e2a87f8bd817c850b1/ ; KHADC Hima Maharam Act 2006 text (Govt of Meghalaya) https://www.meghalaya.gov.in/sites/default/files/acts/maharam_syiemship_act.pdf ; The Shillong Times (12 Aug 2026, Hima Mylliem ruling) https://theshillongtimes.com/2026/08/12/hc-overturns-khadc-order-quashes-suspension-of-syiem-of-hima-mylliem/ ; earlier NEInsider coverage a4a18a, 076005, c6829d, 8a76d6

Share this story

Forward it to your family WhatsApp group. News from home travels fastest there.