Skip to content

Wed 18 Nov 2026

NEInsider
Breaking

Sikkim · Politics · Gangtok

Sikkim HC upholds sacking of its own Protocol Officer, flags nepotism

One post was advertised but three people were hired, one of them after a missed deadline. The Chief Justice said the case was not an isolated one and called for institutional introspection.

By · AI news writer · Published · 5 min read

View of Gangtok city from the ropeway
View of Gangtok city from the ropeway. Photo: Subhrajyoti07 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The High Court of Sikkim has upheld the termination of a Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer appointed by its own administration last year, ruling that her appointment was illegal from the start and warning that the case was not an isolated one.

Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque dismissed the writ petition filed by Smriti Chettri in a judgment delivered on November 16, Sikkim Express reported. The legal news site Verdictum, which also reported the ruling, said the court described the circumstances as "not a mere blemish on the institutional fabric, but a cancerous growth capable of eating away the very soul of this great institution".

How one vacancy became three appointments

The timeline set out in the two reports:

  • November 3, 2025: The High Court advertised one vacant post of Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer (Group C, Level 8). The last date for applications was November 15, with interviews on November 19.
  • November 18, 2025: Chettri, initially rejected for lacking an experience certificate, submitted it three days late and was allowed to sit the interview.
  • November 21, 2025: After the interview, the then Chief Justice converted two Lower Division Assistant-cum-Typist posts into Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer posts by notification.
  • November 25, 2025: A selection list named three candidates, including Chettri. All three were appointed.
  • December 1, 2025: A clarification notice was issued, in the court's words "apparently in response to the public outrage", Verdictum reported.
  • April 21, 2026: The Full Court decided to end Chettri's service because her appointment went beyond the single advertised vacancy. The termination order followed on July 16, 2026, and she challenged it under Article 226.

Why the court said the appointment was void

The judgment gave four grounds:

  • Late document: Accepting the experience certificate after the cut-off effectively extended the deadline for one candidate. "The level playing field, which is required to be maintained on the basis of the prescribed cut-off date, has thus been breached," the judgment said, as quoted by Sikkim Express.
  • Beyond the vacancy: Relying on the Supreme Court's 2010 ruling in Rakhi Ray v. High Court of Delhi, the court held that filling posts beyond those notified violates Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution.
  • No written exam: Rule 6 of the High Court of Sikkim (Recruitment, Conditions of Service and Conduct) Rules, 1998 requires a competitive examination for direct recruitment. The court held that this is mandatory for Group C posts and above, and that even the Chief Justice cannot waive it using residuary powers under Rules 14 and 19. Selection "solely through a viva-voce clearly lacks the requisite transparency and give rise to serious concerns regarding nepotism," Verdictum quoted the bench as saying.
  • No state sanction: The Chief Justice can create posts under Article 229, but appointments to new posts need the state government's sanction under Rule 13 of the Sikkim Government Establishment Rules, 1974, the court said.

The court rejected the argument that an innocent employee should not suffer for administrative mistakes. "Sympathy cannot legitimize illegality, nor can any right flow from a wrong," it said, according to both reports. Verdictum quoted the bench as saying she "must, therefore, march out of this institution through the front door of law, as she entered into this institution through the backdoor".

Not an isolated case

The Chief Justice noted that this was one of several cases over the preceding two years involving appointments allegedly made in violation of legal requirements, Sikkim Express reported. The judgment called for the case to be "the starting point for a process of institutional introspection and renewal".

It is the second time this month that the High Court has acted on how its own administration handled hiring. On November 4, the Full Court suspended Mangan District and Sessions Judge Prajwal Khatiwada pending disciplinary proceedings. Those proceedings involve 33 charges over promotions, upgradations and appointments during his earlier tenure as Registrar General. Khatiwada denies the charges. Neither report links him to the Protocol Officer case.

What this means for job-seekers in Sikkim

For anyone applying to the High Court, the ruling sets out three clear limits: an interview alone cannot be used to fill posts of Group C and above, deadlines cannot be bent for individual candidates, and the number of people hired cannot exceed the number of posts advertised.

Elsewhere in the region, the Mizoram government this week ordered an inquiry after the state Public Service Commission found its marks for storekeeper posts were wrong after 15 people had already been appointed.

What happens next

Chettri previously worked for the Sikkim government, and her High Court probation had not been confirmed. The court gave her liberty to pursue her lien in that earlier job, both reports said.

Neither report says whether she plans to appeal, or what happens to the other two people appointed in the same round, or which other appointments the Chief Justice was referring to. NEInsider will update this story if the High Court administration announces a review or further action.

Compiled by NEInsider with AI assistance from the sources credited below. How we use AI

Sources and credits. With inputs from Sikkim Express https://sikkimexpress.com/news-details/sikkim-high-court-dismisses-plea-challenging-termination-of-protocol-officer ; Verdictum https://www.verdictum.in/sikkim-high-court/smriti-chettri-protocol-cum-liaison-officer-backdoor-entry-nepotism-1625923 ; earlier NEInsider coverage 33923d, 59b871, 8cf917

Share this story

Forward it to your family WhatsApp group. News from home travels fastest there.