Skip to content

Mon 16 Nov 2026

NEInsider
Breaking

Tripura · Crime · Sepahijala

Tripura HC: pay Rs 4 lakh for convict singled out to clean jail dog's waste

The prisons department fought a human rights commission order for a year. The High Court's 16-page ruling says such orders bind the state and gives it a month to pay.

By · AI news writer · Published · 4 min read

The Tripura High Court has ordered the state's prisons department to pay Rs 4 lakh to the widow and children of Dilip Debbarma, a convict who died by suicide inside Kendriya Sansodhanagar, the central jail at Bishalgarh, in October 2024, after the Tripura Human Rights Commission (THRC) found he alone had been made to clean a jail dog's waste every day.

A division bench of Chief Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao and Justice Biswajit Palit dismissed the Inspector General of Prisons' writ petition, WP(C) No. 710 of 2026, on November 11. The 16-page judgment, read by NEInsider, gives the department one month "without fail" to carry out all of the commission's directions and report compliance to the court. The ruling has been reported by The Times of India, ThePrint and LiveLaw.

What the commission found

Debbarma, from Mohan Chandra Para under Jirania police station in West Tripura, was serving 12 years' rigorous imprisonment after a 2016 conviction by a West Tripura sessions court for kidnapping and rape. He was found dead in a prison toilet at about 9 am on October 23, 2024.

In complaint No. 81 of 2024, the commission found that the jail kept a German Shepherd under an official office order, and that Debbarma was the only rigorous-imprisonment convict ever assigned to clean the dog's room. If the jail ordered a dog kept, the commission said, it should have arranged cleaning by convicts paid wages in rotation; giving the job to one man "indicates discrimination."

It also found warder Raju Debbarma prima facie negligent: he sat in the CCTV control room while the dog's room was outside camera coverage. The commission held that Debbarma's rights under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution were violated, recommended a departmental inquiry against the warder and other staff, and allowed the government to recover the Rs 4 lakh from those responsible.

How the state tried to undo it

The judgment sets out a long paper trail:

  • December 16, 2025: THRC final order; Rs 4 lakh to be paid within 30 days, action-taken report due by February 3, 2026.
  • January 31, 2026: The IG Prisons asks for three more months.
  • February 20 and 25, 2026: The department says it never received the order; the commission sends a copy and extends the deadline to May 2, 2026.
  • March 31, 2026: A Judicial Magistrate's inquiry report, which found suicide and said no culpability could be attributed to jail staff, reaches the prisons directorate.
  • July 10, 2026: The department seeks a review on the strength of that report. The commission rejects it on July 13 and again on July 31 as time-barred.

The High Court sided with the commission on every point. A magistrate's inquiry under Section 196 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita can only establish the apparent cause of death, the bench said, citing the Supreme Court's 2003 ruling in Amar Singh v. Balwinder Singh; to the extent the magistrate commented on jail staff's negligence, "he had no jurisdiction." Relying on a Madras High Court Full Bench (Abdul Sathar, 2021), it held that a human rights commission's recommendation under Section 18 of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 is binding and enforceable.

The bench also noted that, two years after the death, the department had not even begun the departmental inquiry it said had to come first.

What this means for Tripura's jails

Tripura's jails are not overcrowded. National Crime Records Bureau data in Prison Statistics India 2023 show Tripura's 14 jails held 1,329 inmates against a capacity of 2,348 (56.6% occupancy) at the end of 2023; the central jail held 597 against 975. The state reported 13 natural deaths in custody that year and no unnatural deaths. Assam reported two prison suicides and Nagaland one; the other NE states reported none. Nationally, 96 of 150 unnatural prison deaths in 2023 were suicides.

The commission's finding was about one convict being singled out, not about caste. But it came 20 days after the Supreme Court, in Sukanya Shantha v. Union of India (October 3, 2024), struck down prison-manual rules that assigned cleaning and sweeping work to prisoners by caste. Both rulings treat the way jail chores are shared out as a question of rights.

What happens next

The prisons department has until about December 11 to pay the family and report compliance to the High Court. The departmental inquiry against the warder and other staff is still pending; the court said the commission's findings will not bind that inquiry. The state could still approach the Supreme Court.

If you or someone you know is struggling, call Tele-MANAS, the government's free mental health helpline, on 14416 or 1-800-891-4416.

Compiled by NEInsider with AI assistance from the sources credited below. How we use AI

Sources and credits. Source: Tripura High Court judgment, WP(C) No. 710 of 2026, IG Prisons v Tripura Human Rights Commission, delivered 11 Nov 2026 (via LiveLaw) https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/11/13/18-inspector-general-of-prisons-tripura-v-tripura-human-rights-commission-anr-711353.pdf ; With inputs from The Times of India (13 Nov) https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/guwahati/tripura-hc-upholds-rs-4l-compensation-for-family-of-prisoner-who-died-by-suicide/articleshow/135801605.cms ; ThePrint (16 Nov) https://theprint.in/judiciary/tripura-high-court-upholds-human-rights-commission-order-on-suicide-of-convict-made-to-clean-dogs-waste/3100040/ ; LiveLaw https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/tripura-high-court/tripura-high-court-human-rights-commission-compensation-recommendations-binding-state-558403 ; NCRB Prison Statistics India 2023 (Tables 1, 8.4) https://www.ncrb.mha.gov.in/uploads/files/PSI-2023.pdf ; LiveLaw on Sukanya Shantha v Union of India (3 Oct 2024) https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/end-caste-based-allotment-of-work-to-prisoners-delete-caste-column-in-prison-registers-supreme-court-271442

Share this story

Forward it to your family WhatsApp group. News from home travels fastest there.