Skip to content

Mon 16 Nov 2026

NEInsider
Breaking

Nagaland

SC clears Nagaland excise constable hiring: 11,521 applied for 46 posts

The Supreme Court has upheld a written test added after the advertisement, ending a five-month freeze on 46 selections. NEInsider read the judgment.

By · AI news writer · Published · 4 min read

Supreme Court of India, New Delhi (file photo)
Supreme Court of India, New Delhi (file photo). Photo: Pinakpani / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Forty-six people selected as Nagaland excise constables in June have waited almost five months to learn whether their selection would stand. On Monday, the Supreme Court settled it. A bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed an appeal by 16 candidates who argued the state had changed the rules of the recruitment halfway through by adding a written test.

The ruling, T. Akon Phom & Ors. vs State of Nagaland & Ors. (2026 INSC 1211), was reported by Court Book and Juris Hour. NEInsider read the full judgment.

250 applicants for every post

The numbers explain why the state wanted a written test. According to figures the Advocate General placed before the court:

  • 11,521 applications came in for 46 posts (40 advertised on April 7, 2025, and six added on May 14, 2025). That is about 250 applicants per post.
  • 5,985 turned up for the physical test in July 2025, roughly half of those who applied.
  • 2,297 cleared it, about 38% of those who took part.
  • 211 were called for interview in February 2026, close to five for every post.
  • 46 were selected. That is 0.4% of all applicants, or about one in 250.

The required qualification for the job is a Class VIII pass. For comparison, the Mizoram Public Service Commission received about 158 valid applications for every candidate it recommended in 2024-25, according to its annual report, which NEInsider analysed on Monday.

What changed, and when

The original advertisement listed two stages: a physical test, then a suitability test or viva-voce. On June 4, 2025, before the physical test, the Departmental Recruitment Board issued a corrigendum adding a written examination, to bring the process in line with other uniformed services, the judgment records. A notification on July 25, 2025 fixed the format: 100 marks, multiple-choice questions at Class VIII level, no negative marking. The exam was held on August 9, 2025.

The candidates' main complaint was about weightage. The written paper carried 100 marks while the viva-voce carried 12, a figure they obtained through an RTI query.

The case went back and forth:

  • October 16, 2025: A single judge of the Gauhati High Court at Kohima quashed both the corrigendum and the physical test. The judge held that the method could not be changed midway.
  • December 3, 2025: A Division Bench let the process continue, but barred the declaration of results without the court's permission.
  • June 23, 2026: The Division Bench allowed the state's appeal. The selection list of 46 was notified on June 29, and the selected candidates sent in their acceptance letters between July 1 and 8.
  • July 7, 2026: The Supreme Court issued notice and granted a stay.

Why the court sided with the state

The bench relied on Rule 5(i)(a) of the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999, which allows direct recruitment through "competitive examination/selection". It held that a Class VIII-level written test fits within that method, so the government did not need to consult the Public Service Commission before using it. Clause 15 of the advertisement allowed the board to correct omissions through notifications and addenda. A 2016 Excise Commissioner memorandum the candidates cited had never been notified, the court said.

The judges also noted that the corrigendum was published in the Nagaland Post and the Eastern Mirror, and that ten of the 16 appellants sat the written exam anyway. They called an objective test a fairer common yardstick than a viva-voce, which they described as "comparatively subjective".

The ruling applies the test set by a five-judge Constitution Bench in Tej Prakash Pathak vs Rajasthan High Court in November 2024, although Monday's judgment does not cite it by name. That case held that selection rules cannot be changed midway unless the service rules or the advertisement allow it, and that any change must still be non-arbitrary. Here, both left room.

What this means for job-seekers

For the 46 selected candidates, the main legal obstacle is gone. With the appeal dismissed, the Excise and Prohibition Department can move on to appointment orders. It has not said when it will issue them.

Departmental boards set up after a September 16, 2024 meeting chaired by the Chief Minister on uniformed-service recruitment now have Supreme Court backing to add objective screening tests where their rules only say "competitive examination/selection". Aspirants preparing for Nagaland Police's Constable (GD) Recruitment 2026 for 1,137 posts should read every corrigendum as closely as the original advertisement.

What to watch: appointment orders for the 46, and whether the department publishes the final marks list, which would show how the 100-mark written test and the 12-mark interview were combined.

Compiled by NEInsider with AI assistance from the sources credited below. How we use AI

Sources and credits. With inputs from Court Book (16 Nov) https://courtbook.in/posts/supreme-court-upholds-written-examination-for-nagaland-excise-constable-recruitment-rejects-candidates-challenge-to-revised-selection-process ; Juris Hour (16 Nov) https://www.jurishour.in/supreme-court/written-test-recruitment-advertisement-valid-rules-permit-prejudice-shown/ ; Source: Supreme Court judgment, T. Akon Phom & Ors. vs State of Nagaland & Ors., Civil Appeal 14203 of 2026, 2026 INSC 1211 (text via CourtKutchehry) https://courtkutchehry.com/judgments/t-akon-phom-and-ors-vs-state-of-nagaland-and-ors ; Supreme Court, Tej Prakash Pathak vs Rajasthan High Court (2024 INSC 847) https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2011/13164/13164_2011_1_1501_57036_Judgement_07-Nov-2024.pdf ; MPSC 34th Annual Report 2024-25 https://mpsc.mizoram.gov.in/uploads/attachments/2025/11/de8e62497fdcd239c155b844d5131454/annual-report-2024-2025.pdf

Share this story

Forward it to your family WhatsApp group. News from home travels fastest there.